How We Rate Casinos
All casinos reviewed at cardamomandco.com are assessed using a consistent, Canada-focused methodology. We test each site from the perspective of a Canadian player, with special attention to Mastercard deposits, CAD support, and provincial rules where applicable. Our ratings reflect real-world usability, safety, and value.
1. Licensing & Regulation
This is the most important factor in our review process. A casino must hold a valid licence from a recognised regulator before we recommend it to Canadian players.
- Malta Gaming Authority (MGA)
- United Kingdom Gambling Commission (UKGC)
- Curaçao eGaming
- Local Canadian provincial licences, such as Ontario’s AGCO or Kahnawake Gaming Commission
We verify licence numbers, check regulator databases, and look for any history of fines, suspensions, or unresolved player complaints. Casinos with no transparent licensing information receive a failing score in this section.
2. Game Selection & Software Providers
A strong casino needs a deep and varied game library from reputable software providers. We evaluate the total number of games, the mix of categories, and the quality of the studios involved.
- Slots: classic, video, progressive jackpots, and Megaways titles
- Live casino: live blackjack, roulette, baccarat, and game shows
- Table games: multiple variants of blackjack, roulette, poker, and craps
We also check for providers such as Evolution, NetEnt, Microgaming, Play’n GO, Pragmatic Play, and others known for fair RNG and high production value. A limited library from unknown or unlicensed providers lowers the score.
3. Bonus Terms & Wagering Requirements
Bonuses are only as good as their terms. We read the full terms and conditions for every welcome offer, reload bonus, and free spins promotion before assigning a score.
- Wagering requirements: We prefer rollover of 35x or lower on bonus funds
- Game weighting: Slots should count 100%, while table games and live casino should contribute fairly
- Max cashout limits: Low or no caps score better
- Time limits: Reasonable expiry periods are preferred
- Eligibility: We check whether CAD accounts and Canadian players can claim the bonus
Unclear terms, hidden restrictions, or predatory conditions significantly reduce this rating.
4. Payment Methods & Withdrawal Speed
As a Mastercard casino review site, we pay close attention to how well each casino handles deposits and withdrawals for Canadian players. We test or verify the available payment methods and document real withdrawal timeframes.
- Credit and debit cards: Mastercard and Visa acceptance, success rates, and fees
- E-wallets: PayPal, Skrill, Neteller, MuchBetter, and Interac
- Bank transfers: processing times and any Canadian banking restrictions
- Crypto: Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, and other supported coins
We score higher for instant deposits, fast withdrawals under 24–48 hours, low or no fees, and support for CAD. Slow pending periods, hidden charges, or limited withdrawal options lower the score.
5. Customer Support
Reliable support is essential for a positive casino experience. We test the support team through multiple channels and at different times of day.
- 24/7 live chat availability and average response time
- Email support quality and resolution speed
- Help centre or FAQ depth and searchability
- Professionalism and accuracy of responses
We prioritise casinos that offer fast, knowledgeable, and friendly support. Long waits, scripted or unhelpful replies, and lack of 24/7 coverage reduce this rating.
6. Mobile Experience
Most Canadian players now gamble on mobile devices. We test the casino on iOS and Android using both mobile browsers and any dedicated apps available in Canadian app stores.
- Responsive design and usability on small screens
- Full game availability on mobile
- Mobile deposit and withdrawal functionality
- Dedicated iOS and Android apps, where offered
- Load times and stability
A seamless mobile experience earns high marks. Broken layouts, missing games, or slow performance lower the score.
7. Responsible Gaming Tools
We expect every casino we recommend to provide practical tools that help players stay in control. We test whether these features are easy to find and actually work.
- Deposit limits: daily, weekly, or monthly caps
- Self-exclusion options
- Cooling-off periods
- Reality checks and session reminders
- Links to Canadian problem gambling resources
Casinos that take responsible gaming seriously score higher. Missing or hidden tools, or difficult self-exclusion processes, lower this rating.
8. Our Rating Scale
Each casino receives a final score from 1 to 10 based on a weighted combination of the sections above. We use the following scale:
- 9.5–10: Outstanding — top-tier safety, game variety, fast payouts, and fair terms
- 8.5–9.4: Excellent — minor drawbacks but highly recommended
- 7.5–8.4: Good — solid casino with a few notable weaknesses
- 6.5–7.4: Fair — playable but with important limitations
- 5.0–6.4: Poor — significant concerns in one or more key areas
- Below 5.0: Avoid — unsafe, unfair, or unreliable
We re-evaluate casinos periodically, especially when ownership, licensing, payment methods, or bonus terms change.